Update on "Save Our Seas" Campaign – The Trawl Ban
The team here at WWF-Hong Kong thought you might be interested in an update on the "Save Our Seas" campaign as it enters a critical period. In 2008 you were one of more than 58,000 people who signed our sustainable fisheries petition, which our then Chairman Markus Shaw handed personally to the Chief Executive.
That petition resulted in Donald Tsang announcing in the 2008 Policy Address that all commercial fishing in our four Marine Parks would eventually be banned. That measure has not yet been enacted as the Agriculture, Fisheries and Conservation Department (AFCD) had few alternative livelihood options to offer the 400 or so commercial fishers who had a license to fish in the Marine Parks and would be impacted by the fishing ban. WWF is confident that commercial fishing will be banned in the Marine Parks in the next year or so providing sufficient alternative livelihood options are made available to the affected fishers.
More recently, the Chief Executive announced in the 2010 Policy Address that another key measure proposed by WWF - to ban all trawling in Hong Kong – would also be put into effect. Bottom trawling, is one of the most destructive legal trawling types of fishing, and has devastated Hong Kong's marine ecosystems in recent decades due to a complete lack of Government controls on where they can operate, and what they can catch. Under the new proposal, all trawling will be banned in Hong Kong.
As banning trawling is going to affect the livelihoods of about 1,400 people in the trawling industry, Government has proposed that the affected fishermen be compensated under a scheme which includes ex-gratia payments (for the trawler owners affected for permanent loss of fishing grounds arising from the proposed trawl ban), voluntary trawler vessel buy-out plan (for the fishers who surrender their vessels), and one-off grants to assist the affected local deckhands employed by the trawler owners.
However, in order for LegCo to approve this bill, sufficient compensation and alternative livelihoods for the affected fishers, and a vision to develop the cultural and economic value of the fishing industry under sustainable practices are needed. WWF is working hard to lobby legislators, and may need your support to voice the importance and benefits of banning trawling in Hong Kong to the ones who love and use the sea. The legislators would need to understand from your point of view why long delays in passing this bill, or even rejection of it will be bad news for Hong Kong.
The bill to be tabled to LegCo by the government in this month is a once-in-a-decade opportunity for us to achieve a win-win situation for all. Overseas cases have demonstrated that unregulated fishing can lead to the collapse of entire fishing communities when stocks disappear. At the next LegCo Food Safety and Environmental Hygiene Panel meeting on the 15th March, WWF will voice our views to LegCo, supporting the banning of highly destructive trawling is very necessary first step, but also pointing out that compensation is only a temporary solution to help those to who want to retire and leave the industry. A holistic policy is also needed to complete the transformation to a healthy and sustainable fishery for Hong Kong – one that will be the envy of the region. A copy of WWF's submission to LegCo can be downloaded at our website.
Over the next few weeks we'll keep you updated on the process, starting with this message, and call for your help if and when it is really needed! Stay tuned.
If you have any comments on the trawl ban or any other marine conservation issue, feel free to email to sos@wwf.org.hk.
The "Save Our Seas" campaign team at WWF
|